top of page
  • Writer's pictureMCM

Turning the Tide: The Critical Role of Tourniquet Conversions in Trauma Care and Reteaching How Tourniquets Should be Taught!


Doctor Converting Tourniquet
Doctor Converting Tourniquet

Emergency tourniquet conversions are critical procedures in trauma care, especially in cases of severe limb injuries where initial tourniquet application is a life-saving intervention. The necessity for tourniquet conversion, primarily from a pre-hospital to a definitive surgical setting, stems from the inherent risks associated with prolonged tourniquet application. This essay explores the importance of emergency tourniquet conversions, outlines the procedure, discusses the risks of prolonged tourniquet use, and argues why the teaching of such conversions should be an integral part of trauma care education.


Importance of Emergency Tourniquet Conversions


The ongoing conflict in Ukraine has highlighted the critical role of first aid training, especially the application of tourniquets for limb injuries. Social media and hands-on training have widely advocated their use. However, there's a concerning downside: improper or excessive use of tourniquets can have dire consequences, including the potential for limb loss, severe physiological repercussions, and even death.


In a sobering revelation from recent research by a Ukrainian vascular surgeon, it's noted that only 24.6% of combat injury cases involving tourniquets in Ukraine warranted their use. This suggests a significant gap in knowledge or judgment in emergency care, underscoring the need for more rigorous training and guidelines to prevent unnecessary complications from improper tourniquet use.


Prolonged use of a tourniquet elevates the risk of serious conditions such as compartment syndrome, vascular thrombosis, rhabdomyolysis, and irreversible muscle tissue death, which can lead to significant tissue damage and often necessitates the amputation of the affected limb. The findings urge caution and precision in the use of tourniquets, emphasizing the fine line between life-saving measures and potential causes of additional harm. ["]


Reasons Why


  • Limb Preservation: Extended tourniquet use can cause ischemia and tissue damage, heightening the risk of losing the limb.

  • Prevention of Compartment Syndrome: Prolonged application of a tourniquet can lead to compartment syndrome, where increased pressure within a muscle compartment causes tissue damage and potentially impairs limb function.

  • Prevention of Reperfusion Injury: Releasing a tourniquet after long periods may result in reperfusion injury, triggering systemic issues such as acidosis, coagulopathy, hypotension, renal failure, and even death.

  • Avoidance of Prolonged Pain and Discomfort: Extended application times can cause significant pain and discomfort, necessitating more analgesia, which may be challenging to provide in environments with limited resources. ["]


Current Recommendations on TC/TR


  • 2015 Reviews: Drew et al. recommended that only medical personnel perform TC, while Shackelford et al. did not specify the level of medical experience required.

  • Professional Guidelines: Guidelines from the Joint Trauma System, Tactical Combat Casualty Care, NAEMT, and the STOP THE BLEED® campaign advise that only medical professionals should carry out TC/TR.

  • Tactical Emergency Casualty Care (TECC) Guidelines: TECC allows for medics and law enforcement officers to perform TC.

In general, the consensus across military and civilian recommendations is that TC/TR procedures should be reserved for medical professionals. ["]


Which Tourniquet to Choose From?


Choosing the best tourniquet for emergency situations, including for tourniquet conversions, involves considering several factors such as effectiveness, ease of use, reliability, and the context in which it will be used (e.g., military vs. civilian emergency medical services). While specific product recommendations can vary based on updates in technology and clinical practice guidelines, as of my last update, some of the most widely respected and used tourniquets in both civilian and military settings include:



Xforce tourniquet conversion
XFORCE Tourniquet


  1. XFORCE Tourniquet: The XFORCE Tourniquet stands out in emergency medical care with its innovative design tailored for efficient tourniquet conversions, crucial in the continuum of trauma care. It's dual ladder strap release levers ensure the tourniquet can be quickly secured and later carefully released, facilitating safe tourniquet conversions in a medical facility. This design not only makes application and adjustment simpler but also adds an extra layer of protection during patient transport, keeping the tourniquet firmly in place and maintaining necessary pressure. Together, these features position the XFORCE Tourniquet as an essential tool for emergency responders and medical professionals, enhancing safety and efficacy from the point of injury through to surgical intervention, thereby improving patient outcomes in trauma situations. Visit https://www.xforcetq.com/ for more information.

Combat Tourniquet
CAT Tourniquet


  1. Combat Application Tourniquet (C-A-T): The C-A-T has been proven effective in controlling severe bleeding in pre-hospital settings.

  2. Special Operations Forces Tactical Tourniquet (SOFTT) and SOFTT-Wide: The SOFTT and its wider version, the SOFTT-Wide, are designed for durability and effectiveness. The wide version, in particular, is favored for its wider band, which distributes pressure more evenly and can be more comfortable for the patient, potentially improving patient outcomes in prolonged use.

When discussing tourniquet conversions, the focus is often on transitioning from the use of a temporary, emergency tourniquet to definitive surgical control of bleeding. This process is usually performed in a controlled medical environment such as a hospital or field hospital setting. The best tourniquet for initial emergency use is one that can be quickly and effectively applied to stop life-threatening bleeding.

It's essential for the choice of tourniquet and subsequent conversion strategies to be based on the latest clinical guidelines and training. Continuous education and practice are crucial for healthcare professionals and first responders to stay updated on the best practices for tourniquet use and conversions.


The Necessity of Teaching Emergency Tourniquet Conversions


Teaching emergency tourniquet conversions is crucial for several reasons. First, it prepares healthcare providers to manage severe limb trauma effectively, optimizing patient outcomes. Second, it raises awareness of the risks associated with prolonged tourniquet use, ensuring that conversions are performed as soon as clinically feasible. Third, it contributes to the development of best practices for tourniquet management in trauma care, guiding research and policy. Lastly, education on this topic enhances interdisciplinary communication and cooperation in trauma teams, ensuring a seamless transition from pre-hospital to definitive care.


Possible Solution


  • Tourniquet Application: In "care under fire" scenarios, immediate control of severe limb bleeding is crucial. A tourniquet should be applied more distally if the bleeding source is clearly above it, or "high and tight" around the limb if the bleeding site is unclear or cannot be closely examined due to the tactical situation.

  • Education: Proper training on tourniquet placement is vital to reduce unnecessary use.

For managing such injuries:

  • Scenarios 1 and 2: Following guidance from Drew or Shackelford, in secure locations, the procedure involves packing the wound, applying pressure, and then loosening the initially applied tourniquet with readiness to tighten a new one if bleeding resumes.

  • Scenarios 3 and 4: Tourniquet conversion (TC) is not advised. Instead, a new tourniquet should be placed 2 to 3 inches above the wound for tourniquet removal (TR), aiding in limb preservation for possible amputation.

  • Continuous Monitoring: Regardless of the situation, it's critical to constantly monitor and reassess the wound for any signs of rebleeding during transport. ["]

Educational Strategies


Incorporating tourniquet conversion training into trauma care education can be achieved through various methods. Simulation-based training provides hands-on experience in a controlled environment, allowing learners to practice the technical and decision-making skills required for safe conversion. Case studies and morbidity and mortality conferences can facilitate discussions on real-life examples, promoting learning from past experiences. Additionally, incorporating this training into continuing education requirements ensures that practicing healthcare providers remain proficient in the latest best practices.


Conclusion


Emergency tourniquet conversions are a critical aspect of trauma care that must be executed with precision to prevent complications arising from prolonged tourniquet use. The risks associated with improper management underscore the importance of education and training in this area. By teaching healthcare providers the correct techniques and decision-making processes for tourniquet conversions, the medical community can improve patient outcomes and minimize the risks associated with these life-saving interventions. As such, the inclusion of tourniquet conversion education in trauma care training programs is not only beneficial but necessary for advancing the quality of care provided to patients with severe limb injuries.


In general, the consensus across military and civilian recommendations is that TC/TR procedures should be reserved for medical professionals. ["]


Reference Citations

For in-depth information and evidence-based guidelines on emergency tourniquet conversions, readers are encouraged to consult sources such as:


Comments


bottom of page